Traditional static analysis methods struggle to detect semantic design flaws, such as violations of the SOLID principles, which require a strong understanding of object-oriented design patterns and principles. Existing solutions typically focus on individual SOLID principles or specific programming languages, leaving a gap in the ability to detect violations across all five principles in multi-language codebases. This paper presents a new approach for this task: a methodology that leverages tailored prompt engineering to assess LLMs on their ability to detect SOLID violations across multiple languages (Java, Python, Kotlin, C#).

We present a systematic benchmark of four leading LLMs—CodeLlama:70B, DeepSeekCoder:33B, Qwen2.5 Coder:32B, and GPT-4o Mini—on their ability to detect violations of all five SOLID principles. To enable this evaluation, we construct a new benchmark dataset of 240 manually validated code examples. Using this dataset, we test four distinct prompt strategies inspired by established zero-shot, few-shot, and chain-of-thought techniques to systematically measure their impact on detection accuracy.

Our emerging results reveal a complex and surprising performance landscape. We find a stark hierarchy among models, with GPT-4o Mini decisively outperforming others, yet even it struggles with challenging principles like DIP. Crucially, we show that prompt strategy has a dramatic impact, but no single strategy is universally best; for instance, a deliberative ENSEMBLE prompt excels at OCP detection while a hint-based EXAMPLE prompt is superior for DIP violations. Across all experiments, detection accuracy is heavily influenced by language characteristics and degrades sharply with increasing code complexity. These initial findings demonstrate that effective, AI-driven design analysis requires not a single “best” model, but a tailored approach that matches the right model and prompt to the specific design context, highlighting the potential of LLMs to support maintainability through AI-assisted code analysis.